122751

(2008) Synthese 160 (3).

DOI: 10.1007/s11229-006-9084-2

Internalism, externalism, and transcendental idealism

Dan Zahavi

pp. 355-374


The analyses of the mind–world relation offered by transcendental idealists such as Husserl have often been dismissed with the argument that they remain committed to an outdated form of internalism. The first move in this paper will be to argue that there is a tight link between Husserl’s transcendental idealism and what has been called phenomenological externalism, and that Husserl’s endorsement of the former commits him to a version of the latter. Secondly, it will be shown that key elements in Husserl’s transcendental idealism, including his rejection of representationalism and metaphysical realism, is shared with a number of prominent contemporary defenders of an externalist view on the mind. Ultimately, however, it will be suggested that the very alternative between internalism and externalism—an alternative based on the division between inner and outer—might be inapplicable when it comes to phenomenological conceptions of the mind–world relation.

References

The feeling of what happens

1999

Antonio Damasio (ed)

San Diego, Harcourt

The structure and content of truth

1990

Donald Davidson

The Journal of Philosophy 87/6

Subjective, intersubjective, objective

2001

Donald Davidson (ed)

Oxford, Oxford University Press

Husserl's epiphenomenology

1988

Hubert L Dreyfus

in: Perspectives on mind, Dordrecht : Reidel

Being-in-the-world

1991

Hubert L Dreyfus (ed)

Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press

Das Problem der Phänomenologie Edmund Husserls

1939

Eugen Fink

Revue internationale de philosophie 1/2

Exorcising the philosophical tradition

2002

Michael Friedman

in: Reading McDowell on mind and world, London : Routledge

The basic problems of phenomenology

1982

Martin Heidegger (ed)

Bloomington, Ind., Indiana University Press

Sein und Zeit

1986

Martin Heidegger (ed)

Tübingen, Niemeyer

Shorter works

1981

Edmund Husserl (ed)

Notre Dame, University of Notre Dame Press

Husserl and Heidegger on human experience

1999

Pierre Keller (ed)

Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

Anti-realism and the epistemology of understanding

1981

John McDowell

in: Meaning and understanding, Berlin : de Gruyter

Putnam on mind and meaning

1992

John McDowell

Philosophical Topics 20/1

Mind and world

1992

John McDowell (ed)

Cambridge, Harvard University Press

Responses

2002

John McDowell

in: Reading McDowell on mind and world, London : Routledge

Cognition and reality

1976

Ulric Neisser (ed)

San Francisco, Freeman

Mind, language and reality: Philosophical papers II

1975

Hilary Putnam (ed)

Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

Meaning and the moral sciences

1978

Hilary Putnam (ed)

London, Routledge & Kegan Paul

Reason, truth and history

1981

Hilary Putnam (ed)

Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

The many faces of realism

1987

Hilary Putnam (ed)

LaSalle, Ill., Open Court

Realism with a human face

1990

Hilary Putnam (ed)

Cambridge, Harvard University Press

Renewing philosophy

1992

Hilary Putnam (ed)

Cambridge, Harvard University Press

The threefold cord: Mind, body, and world

1999

Hilary Putnam (ed)

New York, Columbia University Press

Externalism: Putting mind and world back together again

2003

Mark Rowlands (ed)

Montreal-Kingston, McGill-Queen's University Press

Science, perception and reality

1963

Wilfrid Sellars (ed)

London, Routledge & Kegan Paul

The quest for reality

2000

Barry Stroud (ed)

Oxford, Oxford University Press

Husserl's intersubjective transformation of transcendental philosophy

1996

Dan Zahavi

Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 27/7

Metaphysical neutrality in Logical investigations

2002

Dan Zahavi

in: One hundred years of phenomenology, Dordrecht : Kluwer

Merleau-Ponty on Husserl: a reappraisal

2002

Dan Zahavi

in: Merleau-Ponty's reading of Husserl, Dordrecht : Kluwer

Husserl's phenomenology

2003

Dan Zahavi (ed)

Stanford, Stanford University Press

Phenomenology and metaphysics

2003

Dan Zahavi

in: Metaphysics, facticity, interpretation, Dordrecht : Kluwer

Phenomenology

2008

Dan Zahavi

in: Routledge companion to twentieth-century philosophy, London : Routledge

This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.